Post by Your Master! on May 26, 2009 18:38:39 GMT -5
The obvious question: Should isabella Marie Swan become a vampire?
For those of you who have read Breaking Dawn, voice your opinion still. Discuss whether or not you think she should have or should not have.
List the Pros and Cons if you must!
My Opinion: I think that Bella is better as a vampire. If she remained human, her child would go on forever without a mother. And even without Renesmee, Edward couldn't live without Bella. So if she died, Edward would find a way to kill himself. And the Cullens' don't need that. Also, it's too risky with Bella as a human. The whole ordeal with Jasper was just one example. Bella is a clumsy person, and blood will shed. During birth of Renesmee (SPOILER), Rosalie tried to attack Bella. During Twilight, Alice fought with herself at the sight of Bella's blood. I also think Bella should become a vampire because it's something she needs. Something she wants. Being with the Cullens' all the time makes Bella stick out from them. And if she grew old, who knows what kind of rumors or even mischief might go around. Some people might start to consider her as a pettifile, because in her 60's, Edward will be so young and attracted to such a ragged old woman. Bella's life wouldn't be complete unless she was a vampire. And the argument would come up alot, therefore causing tension and stress between not only the couple, but also the families.
I think Bella should have taken more things into consideration when she made the choice that she wanted to be a vampire. She should've planned more and thought about it plenty. Her act was sort of selfish and her wish was insensitive and sort of ignorant, considering the things she left out and the things she had forgotten. Her mind may not have swayed, had she thought more of her dream, but her actions would have differed and varied than what really went down.
And BTW, although I think she should have her wish, I still dislike her. lolz.
For those of you who have read Breaking Dawn, voice your opinion still. Discuss whether or not you think she should have or should not have.
List the Pros and Cons if you must!
My Opinion: I think that Bella is better as a vampire. If she remained human, her child would go on forever without a mother. And even without Renesmee, Edward couldn't live without Bella. So if she died, Edward would find a way to kill himself. And the Cullens' don't need that. Also, it's too risky with Bella as a human. The whole ordeal with Jasper was just one example. Bella is a clumsy person, and blood will shed. During birth of Renesmee (SPOILER), Rosalie tried to attack Bella. During Twilight, Alice fought with herself at the sight of Bella's blood. I also think Bella should become a vampire because it's something she needs. Something she wants. Being with the Cullens' all the time makes Bella stick out from them. And if she grew old, who knows what kind of rumors or even mischief might go around. Some people might start to consider her as a pettifile, because in her 60's, Edward will be so young and attracted to such a ragged old woman. Bella's life wouldn't be complete unless she was a vampire. And the argument would come up alot, therefore causing tension and stress between not only the couple, but also the families.
I think Bella should have taken more things into consideration when she made the choice that she wanted to be a vampire. She should've planned more and thought about it plenty. Her act was sort of selfish and her wish was insensitive and sort of ignorant, considering the things she left out and the things she had forgotten. Her mind may not have swayed, had she thought more of her dream, but her actions would have differed and varied than what really went down.
And BTW, although I think she should have her wish, I still dislike her. lolz.
